Mifid complex and noncomplex financial instruments for the purposes of the directives appropriateness requirements cesr consultation paper cesr09295. The markets in financial instruments directive mifid is the. Mifid ii and investor protection whats new for asset managers. The european securities and markets authority esma is consulting on guidelines for the distribution of investment products under the markets in financial instruments directive mifid ii. Glossary of useful terms linked to markets in financial.
Mifid appropriateness test is to prevent complex products from. At first glance this seems reasonable, however, unfortunately the definition of complex within the mifid ii directive text and the current esma technical advice to the commission dated 19 december. Efamas esmas paper on draft guidelines on complex debt. The mifid markets in financial instruments directive is a european directive that regulates the provisions of investment services and, therefore, directly affects how credit institutions or investment companies advise on or sell financial products to their customers or potential customers. The directive requires investment firms to conduct an appropriateness test on retail clients for products classified as complex, to determine whether or. Article 38 of the mifid implementing directive will include two new types of complex instrument in relation to which an appropriateness assessment should be carried out. Is the best execution obligation changing under mifid ii. The main changes being introduced by mifid ii are as set out below. It does not categorically intend to disregard whole product categories. Certificates as defined in article 2 1 27 of mifid ii. They should therefore still qualify as non complex under the mifid ii regime. Esma expects to promote greater convergence in the classification of complex or noncomplex financial instruments or structured deposits for the purposes of. The fca has issued clarification on whether investment trusts and other non ucits funds will be classified as non complex under mifid ii after discrepancies appeared to emerge between the body and. Noncomplexity through the eyes of mifid springerlink.
We need to know about the business the applicant firm intends to carry on so we can ensure that it is authorised for the correct regulated activities, investment types and client types, and assess the adequacy of its resources. Less complex products are not generally better suitable. To classify financial instruments as complex or noncomplex as defined by mifid ii, six uses a multilevel rule set through which the various requirements defined by the regulator are taken into account and implemented. Mifid complex and noncomplex financial instruments for the purposes of the directive. Mifid complex and non complex financial instruments for the. Under the mifid i directive applying till 3 january 2018 financial instruments were also listed in the analogous section c, supplemented, however, by articles 38 and 39 of the regulation ec no 12872006 of 10 august 2006 implementing directive 200439ec of the european parliament and of the council as regards recordkeeping obligations for. Mifid ii is made up of two parts, the mifid ii directive 201465eu and the mifir regulation 2014600eu, which together are referred to as mifid ii in this briefing. Clarification of criteria for complexity of instruments the test for noncomplex instruments in the mifid ii directive includes a reference to other noncomplex financial instruments. Draft guidelines on complex debt instruments and structured deposits, 24 march 2015 esma 2015610. Esma consultation paper on mifid iimifir esma2014549. Mifid ii and nurs the complex funds conundrum continues. Section 4 other noncomplex financial instruments under art. Esma final report on guidelines on complex instruments and. Clarification of criteria for complexity of instruments the test for non complex instruments in the mifid ii directive includes a reference to other non complex financial instruments.
Mifid i brought more competitive and integrated eu financial. Some financial instruments are not covered by mifid and are. Cesr invites responses to this consultation paper by 17 july 2009. Mifid ii has narrowed the list of non complex instruments compared to the definition of non complex as per mifid i which has resulted in an increase in the scope of appropriateness. Complex and noncomplex financial instruments for the purposes of the directives appropriateness requirements the financial services consumer panel was established under the financial services and markets act 2000 by the financial services authority to represent the interests of financial services consumers. Other non complex financial instruments proposed new article 196av cesr repeats its view that it is not practicable for article 196 to determine the treatment in respect of all types of. Mifid complex and noncomplex financial instruments for the purposes of the directives appropriateness requirements cesr09295. Noncomplexity through the eyes of mifid request pdf. Application for authorisation supplement for securities and futures firms noncomplex notes 1 regulatory business plan. Questions and answers mifid complex and non complex financial instruments for the purposes of the directives appropriateness requirements. Mifir is a regulation and therefore is directly applicable in each member state.
Mifid financial instruments and its views on how these were likely to fit within the complexnoncomplex categories of financial instruments for the purposes of the directives appropriateness requirements. Structured products market blasts mifid ii complexity test. Whilst article 254 in mifid ii allows investment firms to provide orderhandling services such as receiving and transmitting of orders and execution of orders on behalf of clients without performing the appropriateness test, this only relates to noncomplex products and more complex products cannot be treated in the same way. Request pdf non complexity through the eyes of mifid the european commission recently published legislative proposals to reform the markets in financial instruments directive mifid. Based on the industrywide approach that ordinary shares and simple cash bonds are deemed noncomplex products, the high degree of transparency and liquid nature of the markets, the amount of. Mifid ii appropriateness approach to implementation to assess what could fall within the final category, other noncomplex financial instruments, the delegated regulation applies a further six criteria which a financial instrument must meet to be deemed noncomplex. The criteria for other noncomplex financial instruments are set out in article 57 of the. Markets in financial instruments directive mifid caixabank. Noncomplex instruments the mifid level 1 directive art.
Mifid ii appropriateness approach to implementation tisa. Mifid ii what will be its impact on the investment fund. Annex i nonexhaustive list of mifid complex noncomplex. Six mifid ii rule set documentation six financial information. A list of questions has been presented and answered in relation to the classification of instrument complexity. Mifid ii product governance the product governance rules under mifid ii, including guidelines issued.
Where an executiononly service relates to noncomplex financial instruments specified in article 196 of the existing mifid and certain other conditions apply, the investment firm can provide. The purchase and sale of the financial instrument is therefore at your own risk. The european securities and markets authority esma has now published their final report on guidelines for complex debt instruments and structured deposits under mifid ii whilst article 254 in mifid ii allows investment firms to provide orderhandling services such as receiving and. Mifid ii, in the commissions draft proposal, splits ucits between complex and non complex. The markets in financial instruments directive is the eu legislation that regulates firms who provide services to clients linked to financial instruments shares, bonds, units in collective investment schemes and derivatives, and the venues where those instruments are traded. Other noncomplex financial instruments proposed new article 196av cesr repeats its view that it is not practicable for article 196 to. Questions and answers mifid complex and non complex financial. Guidelines on complex instruments deloitte luxembourg. Mifid complex and non complex financial instruments for the purposes of the directives appropriateness requirements cesr09295. For this purpose, the criteria are laid down in mifid l2, article 38 provision of services in noncomplex instruments as follows. Mifid complex and noncomplex financial instruments for.
Danish shareholders association is the organisation representing private investors in denmark. In its consultation paper, 6 cesr outlined its views on the interpretation and application of article 196 and article 38 and invited comments from market participants. However, where an executiononly service relates to non complex financial instruments specified in article 196 of mifid and certain other conditions apply, the investment firm can provide the service to the client without having to carry out the appropriateness assessment. Complex and or packaged products for all investor types including retail. The markets in financial instruments directive mifid1 includes. Danish shareholders association finds that the consultation paper is a fine and. The evolution of financial markets has exposed the need to strengthen the framework for the regulation of markets in financial instruments, including where trading in such markets takes place overthecounter otc, in order to increase transparency, better protect investors, reinforce confidence, address unregulated areas, and ensure that.
Mifid appropriateness test is to prevent complex products from being sold on an executiononly. Mar 31, 2010 in its feedback statement on complex vs. Where firms are selling products on a nonadvised basis, mifid i requires. While mifid i labeled all ucits noncomplex, mifid ii deems all structured ucits complex. They should therefore still qualify as noncomplex under the mifid ii regime. Mifid ii also identifies the conditions under which these products cannot be classified as noncomplex with the result of narrowing the list of noncomplex instruments currently regulated by. Article 254 of directive 201465eu a financial instrument which is not explicitly specified in article 254a of directive 201465eu shall be considered as noncomplex for the purposes of article 254avi of directive 201465eu if it satisfies the following criteria it does not fall within article 4144c of, or points 4 to 11 of section c of annex i to directive 201465eu. Mifid ii decreases the scope of financial instruments deemed to be noncomplex for example, structured ucits thereby requiring an appropriateness assessment for additional financial instruments.
The fca has issued clarification on whether investment trusts and other nonucits funds will be classified as noncomplex under mifid ii after discrepancies appeared to emerge between the body and. Mifid ii and investor protection whats new for asset. The following classification into complex and noncomplex products is indicative and does not. Structured thoughts news for the financial services. The significance of this distinction under mifid is that only financial instruments that are noncomplex can be sold to customers on an execution only basis without first having to assess the appropriateness of. Mifid ii will be implemented into uk law on 3 january 2018 and will replace directive 200439ec mifid i. The markets in financial instruments directive ii mifid ii does not define. May 14, 20 the european commission recently published legislative proposals to reform the markets in financial instruments directive mifid.
Esma expects to promote greater convergence in the classification of complex or noncomplex financial instruments or structured deposits for the purposes of the appropriateness testexecutiononly business in accordance with article 253 and 254 of mifid ii. Investment firms licensed under the eus markets in. Dec 01, 2015 mifid ii also identifies the conditions under which these products cannot be classified as noncomplex with the result of narrowing the list of noncomplex instruments currently regulated by mifid. Many aifs today meet the qualitative criteria of instruments being noncomplex and according to our understanding will also comply with the two new criteria suggested by esma. Esma final report on complex debt instruments and structured. This means that some products will now need to be shifted from a complex to a noncomplex categorization, which will, in turn, change requirements for appropriateness. The european commission recently published legislative proposals to reform the markets in financial instruments directive mifid. Summary of the product governance policy goldman sachs. This note elaborates on the proposed shift in classification of structured undertakings for collective investment in transferable securities ucits. Nov 30, 2015 esma expects to promote greater convergence in the classification of complex or noncomplex financial instruments or structured deposits for the purposes of the appropriateness testexecutiononly business in accordance with article 253 and 254 of mifid ii.
Directive 201465eu on mifid ii, repealing directive 200439ec. Regulation eu no 6002014 on markets in financial instruments mifir as an eu regulation, mifir is binding in its entirety and directly applicable, its content. Mifid complex and noncomplex financial instruments for the. Many aifs today meet the qualitative criteria of instruments being non complex and according to our understanding will also comply with the two new criteria suggested by esma. Deadline these guidelines apply from 3 january 2017. Industry trade bodies have reiterated calls to overhaul mifid ii proposals that treat nonucits products as complex instruments, amid signs european regulators may be close to backing down. Under eu law, the complexity of an instrument is determined by the. Level 1 firms are small with noncomplex investment strategies. Aside from concerns on financial market structure and transparency regulation,1 one of the two key areas of concern for mifid has been. Mifid ii appropriateness approach to implementation. Consumer panel response to cesr consultation document. Mifid ii aims to enhance the efficiency and integrity of the. Investment firms licensed under the eus markets in financial.
All contributions should be submitted online via cesrs website under the heading. Noncomplex financial instruments financial instruments as referred to in subparagraphs a e of the. To classify financial instruments as complex or non complex as defined by mifid ii, six uses a multilevel rule set through which the various requirements defined by the regulator are taken into account and implemented. Mifid complex and non complex financial instruments for. The initial capital requirement is 50,000 or 125,000. Mifid ii itself as a directive requires implementation at a national level. Investment firms licensed under the eus markets in financial instruments directive directive 200439ec mifid mifid was implemented into law in ireland by the european communities markets in financial instruments regulations 2007 as amended the mifid regulations.
1023 441 401 710 1196 981 1232 916 1076 614 856 1584 825 1133 4 1387 1025 1230 576 1661 1439 422 771 1014 346 673 205 634 198 630 232 965 239 108 530 23 394